SCF Baseball has produced 49 NJCAA All-Americans in its 60 years of collegiate baseball. They include:
2021
- Tucker Mitchell
2018
- CJ Alexander
2011
- LB Dantzler
- Nick Goody
2010
- Alex Burgos
2008
- Scott Rembisz
- Taylor Hashman
2006
- Kevin Clark
2005
- Angel Mercado
2004
- Jason Louwsma
2002
- Larry Grayson
1997
- Paul Stryhas
1996
- Ryan Channel
1985
- Joey Fernandez
- Tom Kane
1981
- Glenn Davis
1980
- Clem Freeman
1972
- John O'Conner
- Keith Smith
- Rick Langford
1969
- Mac Scarce
- Johnny Grubb
- Pat Osburn
1968
- Ron Cash
- Robin Flake
- David Moates
1967
- Walter Lampmann
- Tom Cook
- Stan Bell
1966
- Walter Lampmann
1965
- John Frye
1964
- Maury Hopkins
- Dick Fernandez
1963
- Dick Treadway
- Paul Dicken
1962
- Allen Payne
- Jim Reed
- Buster Hardy
1961
- Don Cunningham
- Larry Hawkins
- Alan Fritcraft
1960
- Jon Barry Wimbish